The Carnal Man (Part 1)
A Sermon on the Carnal Man from Romans 7:14-15
Originally preached Nov. 13, 1959
Scripture
14For we know that the law is spiritual: but I am carnal, sold under sin. 15For that which I do I allow not: for what I would, that do I not; but what I hate, that do I.
Sermon Description
The spiritual identity of the man in Romans 7:14-25 is the driving question interpreters face as they approach one of Scriptures most perplexing passages. After providing an introduction to the passage in the previous message, Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones begins to parse out in greater detail his own view of Romans 7:14-25 in this sermon. With pastoral sensitivity Dr. Lloyd-Jones maintains humility when expounding the passage, noting how truly difficult the section of Scripture is. He encourages his audience to not give up on difficult texts. He argues that Paul’s defense of the law remains the key contextual detail one must keep in mind. In this sermon Dr. Lloyd-Jones has his keen exegetical eye set on the phrase “sold under sin.” Of whom is such a statement true? Is this a description of an unregenerate man? Dr. Lloyd-Jones argues that it cannot be so due to the fact that an unregenerate man does not affirm that he has such a condition. Is this a description of a regenerate man? Lloyd-Jones says that it cannot be since such a view contradicts Paul’s description of a regenerate man elsewhere in Romans. What is the solution then? Listen to this fascinating sermon by Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones as he works through this complex and complicated passage in Paul’s most famous letter
Sermon Breakdown
- The passage under consideration is Romans 7:14-25. This section has led to much discussion and controversy due to its difficulty.
- We should not be discouraged by the difficulty of this passage. We should rely on the Holy Spirit for enlightenment and resolve to study it diligently.
- The overriding theme of this section is what the law cannot do - it cannot justify or sanctify us.
- The subsidiary theme is that the law condemns and kills us not because of any fault in itself, but because of the sin in us.
- Verse 14: We know the law is spiritual, but I am carnal, sold under sin. This is a key statement. "Sold under sin" means in slavery to sin. Sin is the master, I am the slave.
- No unregenerate person could make such a statement about themselves. They do not understand the spiritual nature of the law or recognize their own carnality and slavery to sin.
- This statement also does not describe the regenerate. They are no longer under sin but under grace. They have died to sin and been freed from its slavery.
- Verse 15: The life of the person described in v.14 is one of frustration, defeat and failure. They do what they do not want to do and do not do what they want to do.
- This verse does not mean the person always does wrong and never right, but describes their life in a balanced, general sense.
- This verse cannot describe the unregenerate, who do not have this inner conflict or hatred of sin. Nor can it fully describe the regenerate, who have been freed from slavery to sin.
- Verse 15 describes someone who sees the spiritual character of the law, wants to keep it, but finds in practice that they cannot. They are carnal, sold under sin, yet desire to obey the law.
Sermon Q&A
Understanding Romans 7:14-15: Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones on the Struggle with Sin
What does Dr. Lloyd-Jones mean when he discusses the difficulty of Romans 7:14-15?
Dr. Lloyd-Jones acknowledges that Romans 7:14-15 is one of the most difficult passages in Scripture. He notes that throughout church history, great scholars and saints have disagreed about its interpretation. Rather than being discouraged by this difficulty, he encourages his audience to:
"Our reaction to difficulty should be thus. It should make us realize our need of the Holy Spirit and the enlightenment that he alone can give... it should create within us a resolve and a resolution to apply ourselves more than we've ever done before to an understanding of these things."
He warns against the modern tendency to reject difficult passages in favor of "simple" teachings, calling this approach "sinful" because it prevents spiritual growth.
What are the key themes of Paul's teaching in this passage?
According to Lloyd-Jones, there are two primary themes in this section:
-
Paul is justifying his teaching about what the law cannot do - "the law can neither justify us nor sanctify us"
-
Though the law becomes the means of our condemnation, this is not because of a defect in the law but because of sin in us
As he states: "The law kills us. Yes. Not because there's anything wrong with the law, but because there is this wrong with us, namely that we are in a state and a condition of sin."
What does the phrase "sold under sin" in Romans 7:14 mean?
Dr. Lloyd-Jones identifies this as the most significant statement in the passage. He explains:
"It means sold or disposed of into slavery. There is no doubt about the meaning. Everybody has agreed there. Sold under sin means that I am sold into a condition of slavery to sin. In other words, I am in a condition of slavery to sin, or I am a slave to sin. Sin is the master and I am the slave."
He emphasizes that this describes the whole person, not just a part: "He is not saying the law is spiritual, but a part of me is carnal... What he says is, I am carnal, I am sold under sin."
Why does Dr. Lloyd-Jones believe this passage cannot describe an unregenerate person?
Lloyd-Jones presents several reasons why this cannot describe an unregenerate (non-Christian) person:
-
"The unregenerate person doesn't understand the nature of the law. No unregenerate man knows that the law is spiritual."
-
"The unregenerate men doesn't realize that he is carnal. He doesn't realize that he is sold under sin."
-
The unregenerate person thinks he is "alive" and doing well spiritually, whereas Paul describes someone conscious of his slavery to sin.
As he concludes: "This verse is enough in and of itself to put right out the suggestion that this is a description of an unregenerate men."
Why does Dr. Lloyd-Jones believe this passage cannot describe a regenerate Christian?
Lloyd-Jones argues this cannot describe a regenerate Christian because:
-
It contradicts Paul's teaching in Romans 5 and 6 about Christians being freed from sin: "We are no longer under sin, we are under grace."
-
In Romans 6:2, Paul states Christians have "died to sin" and asks, "How shall we that died to sin live any longer therein?"
-
Romans 6:14 declares "sin shall not have dominion over you, for you are not under the law but under grace."
-
In Romans 6:18, Paul states believers are "made free from sin" and "became the slaves of righteousness."
Lloyd-Jones asks: "How can you say about such a man that he's carnal, that he is sold under sin? He was, but he's no longer."
Who then is Paul describing in this passage according to Lloyd-Jones?
Dr. Lloyd-Jones suggests Paul is describing a person in a specific spiritual state - someone who:
- Has come to understand the spiritual nature of God's law
- Admires the law and desires to keep it
- Finds in practice that he cannot keep it
As he concludes: "He sees the spiritual character of the law. He admires it, he wants to keep it. He cannot keep it... This is the statement about a man who is carnal, sold under sin, who nevertheless sees the spiritual character of the law."
This represents a transitional state in spiritual understanding - someone who sees their need but hasn't yet fully embraced the freedom in Christ that Paul describes in Romans 8.
The Book of Romans
Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones
Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones (1899-1981) was a Welsh evangelical minister who preached and taught in the Reformed tradition. His principal ministry was at Westminster Chapel, in central London, from 1939-1968, where he delivered multi-year expositions on books of the bible such as Romans, Ephesians and the Gospel of John. In addition to the MLJ Trust’s collection of 1,600 of these sermons in audio format, most of these great sermon series are available in book form (including a 14 volume collection of the Romans sermons), as are other series such as "Spiritual Depression", "Studies in the Sermon on the Mount" and "Great Biblical Doctrines". He is considered by many evangelical leaders today to be an authority on biblical truth and the sufficiency of Scripture.