MLJ Trust Logo Image
Sermon #3221

Who Art Thou O Man?

A Sermon on Romans 9:18-24

Originally preached Feb. 1, 1963

Scripture

Romans 9:18-24 ESV KJV
So then he has mercy on whomever he wills, and he hardens whomever he wills. You will say to me then, “Why does he still find fault? For who can resist his will?” But who are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is molded say to …

Read more

Sermon Description

Who is responsible for a hard heart? Is it something one does or something God does to them? In this sermon on Romans 9:18–24 titled “Who Art Thou, O Man?” Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones introduces the challenging subject of God’s sovereignty and humanity’s responsibility. Scripture speaks of God’s sovereign choice first of the nation of Israel and then of individuals within that nation such as Jacob over Esau. Yet a person’s decision to reject God is also seen. How can God allow such rebellion to exist? Dr. Lloyd-Jones explains that in many cases, it is so that God’s power may be seen in how He handles evil. Yet some may ask, how can God find fault with people since He is sovereign? The question is valid since even Paul incorporates it in this passage, yet before it can be addressed, Dr. Lloyd-Jones encourages examination of motive so that one does not question God from a place of arrogance or indignation. A person’s spirit must be contrite, knowing that their understanding is limited. He encourages careful consideration of who one is and to follow the pathway of Moses before he walked on holy ground or of Isaiah who cautiously and humbly responded to God’s glory.

Sermon Breakdown

  1. The apostle begins by rebuking the questioner for replying against God in a contentious spirit. He emphasizes the contrast between man and God - "who art thou, o man?"

  2. The apostle asserts God's absolute freedom and sovereignty. God has mercy on whom he will have mercy and hardens whom he will harden.

  3. The apostle uses the analogy of the potter and the clay to illustrate God's sovereignty over man. Man is like clay, and God is the potter who has power over the clay.

  4. The apostle explains that he has been quoting Scripture, not just giving his own opinion. Therefore, to object is to object to God's own teaching about himself.

  5. The apostle says we must approach this subject, and all of Scripture, with the right spirit - humble, reverent, and willing to listen. We must realize our smallness before God.

  6. Examples of the right spirit are seen in Moses, Joshua, Job, and Isaiah. They humbled themselves when confronted with God's glory and majesty.

  7. The apostle rebukes the "fleshy mind" that intrudes into things it has not seen and is puffed up with its own opinions.

  8. God hides truth from the wise and prudent but reveals it to "babes" - those with a childlike, humble spirit.

  9. We must confess we have often expressed arrogant opinions about God's truth. We need forgiveness and grace.

  10. We need God's Spirit to give us a humble, teachable spirit as we study His Word. We must become "fools" to worldly wisdom to gain true wisdom.

Sermon Q&A

Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones on Romans 9: Understanding God's Sovereignty and Man's Responsibility

What is the main argument Paul is addressing in Romans 9:18-24?

According to Dr. Lloyd-Jones, Paul is addressing objections to his teaching on God's sovereignty in election. The objection is summarized in verse 19: "Why doth he yet find fault for who hath resisted his will?" In other words, if God sovereignly decides whom to save and whom to harden, how can He justly hold people accountable for their actions? This objection arises after Paul has stated that "He hath mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth."

How does Lloyd-Jones explain God's hardening of Pharaoh's heart?

Dr. Lloyd-Jones explains that God didn't create Pharaoh to be evil, but rather "took pharaoh as he was a sinner and an unbeliever, God hardened his heart for his own eternal purpose." He points out that both statements in Exodus are true: "God hardened the heart of pharaoh and that pharaoh hardened his own heart." God "aggravated and accentuated what he was in order to serve his own purpose," which was to demonstrate His power. By increasing Pharaoh's resistance, God was able to perform greater miracles that displayed His power and made His name "declared throughout all the earth."

What does Dr. Lloyd-Jones say is wrong with the common objection to the doctrine of election?

Dr. Lloyd-Jones identifies that the primary problem is the spirit in which the objection is raised. He points out that Paul rebukes not the question itself but the questioner's attitude: "Nay, but, o men, who art thou that repliest against God?" The word "repliest" indicates a spirit of contention and contradiction. The objector is not humbly seeking understanding but arrogantly suggesting God is unjust. Lloyd-Jones states, "The Bible never rebukes a genuine perplexity and difficulty. But what it is so very concerned about is the inquiry and the form in which it's made."

How does Lloyd-Jones refute the idea that God chooses people based on foreseen faith?

Lloyd-Jones argues that if Paul were teaching that God simply chooses people based on His foreknowledge of who would believe, no one would object to that teaching. He states: "Nobody would take any objection to that. Everybody'd say, quite right too... They both had the same chance. One decided to believe, one decided not to. Nobody'd have any complaint at all." The very existence of the objection in verse 19 proves that Paul is teaching something more challenging - that "salvation is entirely the result of the sovereign will and election of God and nothing to do with us at all."

What attitude does Dr. Lloyd-Jones say we should have when approaching difficult biblical doctrines?

Dr. Lloyd-Jones emphasizes that we must approach Scripture with humility, reverence, and a teachable spirit. He quotes several biblical examples (Moses at the burning bush, Joshua meeting the captain of the Lord's host, Job, and Isaiah) where people were humbled in God's presence. He states we should "take off the shoes from off your feet" because "the ground whereon you're standing is holy ground." He warns against discussing Scripture as we would discuss other matters, saying: "You have your right to your opinion in every other respect, in every other matter. Not here. Here, you take off your shoes. You've got to become as a little child."

What does Lloyd-Jones say is the relationship between God's sovereignty and man's responsibility in Romans 9?

Dr. Lloyd-Jones notes that this chapter emphasizes God's sovereignty, while chapter 10 will emphasize man's responsibility. He says the passage "does teach us the relationship of God's sovereignty and man's responsibility, giving equal weight to birth." He indicates that Paul is not teaching fatalism or that humans are merely machines, but rather establishing God's sovereign right before addressing human responsibility. The apostle "emphasizes best the sovereignty of God, the responsibility of men," showing how these two great truths exist together in Scripture.

Why does Dr. Lloyd-Jones say this objection to election has nothing to do with modern thinking?

Dr. Lloyd-Jones points out that "There is nothing new in this objection to this doctrine. This isn't a 20th century objection. They were objecting to the same doctrine in the first century. They've been objecting to it ever since." He dismisses the idea that modern knowledge makes this doctrine more problematic: "It's got nothing to do with modern learning, modern knowledge, modern science, nothing at all. Let's get rid of that. We're not being clever nor modern when we argue against this."

What is the significance of Paul's illustration about the potter and the clay?

Lloyd-Jones explains that Paul uses the potter and clay illustration to emphasize the contrast between man and God. He says, "The contrast is between man and God, the thing formed, and the one who forms a lump of clay and the puzzle." This illustration highlights man's complete dependence on God and God's sovereign right to do as He pleases with His creation. It's meant to humble the questioner by showing the vast difference between the Creator and the created.

The Book of Romans

Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones

Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones (1899-1981) was a Welsh evangelical minister who preached and taught in the Reformed tradition. His principal ministry was at Westminster Chapel, in central London, from 1939-1968, where he delivered multi-year expositions on books of the bible such as Romans, Ephesians and the Gospel of John. In addition to the MLJ Trust’s collection of 1,600 of these sermons in audio format, most of these great sermon series are available in book form (including a 14 volume collection of the Romans sermons), as are other series such as "Spiritual Depression", "Studies in the Sermon on the Mount" and "Great Biblical Doctrines". He is considered by many evangelical leaders today to be an authority on biblical truth and the sufficiency of Scripture.