MLJ Trust Logo Image
Sermon #NF45

Preaching: The Anglican and Puritan Divide

The Theological Roots of Two Radically Different Views of the Pulpit

Originally preached Dec. 26, 1977

Sermon Description

In this address delivered at the 1977 Westminster Conference, Dr. Lloyd-Jones argues that the difference between Anglican and Puritan views of preaching was not a peripheral disagreement but a direct expression of two fundamentally different theologies. Where Anglicanism treated preaching as an accessory to liturgy and sacrament — something edifying when present, but not essential — the Puritans regarded the faithful exposition of Scripture as the supreme act of the church's life, the very means by which God himself speaks to his people. Dr. Lloyd-Jones traces this conviction through the Reformers, through Queen Elizabeth's suppression of the "prophesyings," through Richard Hooker's preference for homilies over living proclamation, and into the defining statements of Thomas Cartwright, William Perkins, and the Westminster Directory — each of which places preaching first and treats all other elements of worship as subordinate to it.

What emerges is not merely a historical account but an urgent word to the contemporary church. At a time when preaching is once again being displaced by entertainment, participation, and sensory spectacle, Dr. Lloyd-Jones insists that the Puritan inheritance must not be lost. True preaching, he contends, is not an essay, not a dramatic performance, and not a discussion — it is a man standing before God and before dying men, delivering the Word of God with plain earnestness, deep learning concealed within plain speech, and fire in the heart. The ideal he sets before the church is Baxter's own: I preached as never like to preach again, and as of dying men to dying men.

Various

Sermon Breakdown

  • The differences between Anglican and Puritan thinking are not peripheral but rooted in fundamentally divergent views of authority, worship, and the nature of the church — preaching being the clearest point where those differences become unavoidable
  • The Anglican tradition, from the Book of Common Prayer through Queen Elizabeth's suppression of the "prophesyings" to Richard Hooker's defence of read homilies, consistently treated preaching as an accessory rather than the central act of the church's gathered life
  • The Puritan conviction, by contrast, placed the faithful exposition of Scripture first in every definition of the true church, regarding it as the ordinary means of salvation and the appointed way by which God himself addresses his people
  • Thomas Cartwright's image of fire stirred and blown captures the Puritan understanding precisely — preaching does not merely inform the mind, it brings the word to life in the heart, giving it heat and application it cannot have when simply read
  • The Puritans insisted that preaching must control even the sacraments, because the sacraments seal the word but do not convey it — Calvin himself declared that communion without a sermon is nothing but a dumb show
  • William Perkins' fourfold method — read the text distinctly, give its sense from Scripture, draw out the doctrine plainly, and apply it to the life and manners of men — represents the Puritan conviction that true exposition must always move from word to doctrine to use, never stopping at mere information
  • The Puritan style was deliberately plain in language but never impoverished in learning — Perkins and others steeped themselves in philosophy, history, and languages while in the study, then concealed all of it in the pulpit, distilling it into the pure essence of the truth for every hearer
  • Puritan preaching was not the dull, heavy, and solemn exercise caricatured by its critics — it was urgent, warm, gesticulatory, intimate, and often fervent to the point of shouting, because these men preached as men who believed that souls were saved or lost by what they declared
  • The prophesyings of the Elizabethan period — gatherings where ministers preached and then discussed one another's sermons — reveal how seriously the Puritans took the training of preachers, and their suppression by the Crown in 1576 shows how threatening that priority of the word appeared to those committed to a liturgical establishment
  • The supreme standard of preaching, drawn from 2 Corinthians 2, is that the preacher stands as a savor of life unto life or death unto death — not as a learned, cultured man offering polished entertainment, but as one speaking in the sight of God and in the name of Christ, conscious that God himself may be heard in the faithful exposition of his Word

Sermon Q&A

Questions and Answers

Why does Dr. Lloyd-Jones describe the Anglican and Puritan differences over preaching as "fundamental" rather than merely stylistic?

Dr. Lloyd-Jones argues that one's view of preaching is never merely a matter of taste or preference — it is always an expression of one's underlying theology. The Anglican tradition, shaped by its commitment to liturgy, sacrament, and a comprehensive national church, could accommodate preaching as a valuable addition without requiring it as the church's central act. The Puritan tradition, by contrast, drew its view of preaching directly from its understanding of Scripture: God speaks to his people through his Word, and the preaching of that Word is the ordinary means of salvation. These are not two approaches to the same task — they are expressions of two different accounts of how God deals with human beings.

What did the Puritans mean when they said that in faithful preaching, God himself is speaking?

This was not a claim that the preacher's words are infallible, but rather a conviction about what preaching is by its very nature. Dr. Lloyd-Jones explains that, for the Puritans, the function of the preacher is to expound and hold before the people the Word of God. Because the message declared is not the message of the preacher but the message of Scripture, and because Scripture is the very Word of God, the faithful expositor may be said to be the instrument through which God himself addresses his congregation. It is a statement about the authority of the Word, not the authority of the man.

How did the Puritans relate preaching to the sacraments, and why does that relationship matter?

The Puritan position — held in varying forms by Calvin and those who followed him — was that the sacraments seal the Word but do not convey it. They are confirmations and certifications of a promise that must first be declared; apart from that declaration, they become what Calvin called "a dumb show." This meant that the sermon was not simply one component among several equal parts of worship, but the supreme act upon which everything else depended. Dr. Lloyd-Jones notes this as a decisive contrast with Anglican sacramentalism, in which the Eucharist held the central place and preaching could be reduced to an accessory.

What did the Puritans mean by "plain preaching," and does that mean they were unlearned men?

Dr. Lloyd-Jones is emphatic on this point. The Puritans were not plain preachers because they lacked learning — many of them were among the most erudite men of their age. William Perkins himself insisted that a preacher should make full use of arts, philosophy, and wide reading in the study. But he equally insisted that all of this should be concealed in the pulpit, never paraded. Thomas Fuller described Perkins as distilling deep scholarship into his preaching the way an infusion distills herbs into a liquid — all the strength was present, none of the bulk was visible. The result was that the most learned man in the congregation met his intellectual match, and the most ignorant man received equal blessing. That is the Puritan ideal, and it is the standard by which Dr. Lloyd-Jones measures all preaching.

Why does Dr. Lloyd-Jones regard this address as urgent for the contemporary church, and not merely a historical survey?

Because the very forces that the Puritans opposed are alive again. Dr. Lloyd-Jones observes that preaching is once more at a discount — displaced by music, performance, dramatic presentations, and calls for congregational participation. He traces this impulse directly to the same instinct the Reformation swept away: the preference for what men can see, do, and feel over the apparently simple act of a man declaring the Word of God. The Puritans understood that this preference is theological, not merely aesthetic — it reflects a view of worship in which man reaches toward God rather than God speaking to man. To recover the Puritan conviction about preaching is, for Dr. Lloyd-Jones, to recover the very heart of Protestant Christianity.

Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones

Dr. Martyn Lloyd-Jones (1899-1981) was a Welsh evangelical minister who preached and taught in the Reformed tradition. His principal ministry was at Westminster Chapel, in central London, from 1939-1968, where he delivered multi-year expositions on books of the bible such as Romans, Ephesians and the Gospel of John. In addition to the MLJ Trust's collection of 1,600 of these sermons in audio format, most of these great sermon series are available in book form (including a 14 volume collection of the Romans sermons), as are other series such as "Spiritual Depression", "Studies in the Sermon on the Mount" and "Great Biblical Doctrines". He is considered by many evangelical leaders today to be an authority on biblical truth and the sufficiency of Scripture.